[maemo-community] Harmattan & Maemo Community

[From: Sunny B]

On Fri, May 6, 2011 at 8:36 AM, Ville M. Vainio <vivainio at gmail.com> wrote:

> On Fri, May 6, 2011 at 3:24 PM, Sunny B <sunnyb7532 at gmail.com> wrote:
>
> > 1)  Clarification of the SW Architecture - Is it Meego Core OS with a
> Nokia
> > custom UI or UX on top?  QGil has said MeeGo APIs, but now Dave Neary
> says
> > some legacy Maemo APIs (in addition?).
>
> Harmattan is evolution of maemo5, with no MeeGo Core lineage. It has
> several components that are shared with MeeGo though. That's why it's
> said to be "meego compatible".
>
> > 3)  MeeGo compliance
>
> Harmattan is not MeeGo compliant at all, starting with the fact that
> it's using deb instead of rpm.
>
> > 5)  To what extent will developers of Maemo5 and Maemo 4.1 apps be
> > comfortable with Harmattan and find it a "natural" extension.
>
> Back-end stuff will feel very familiar, GUI development is supposed to
> be done in QML (familiarity of which can be argued, as it's an overall
> new phenomenon).
>
>
> > I agree with Andrew that the thing is a mess.  I think that's beyond the
> > control of maemo.org.  Perhaps we can try to clarify things through
> > discussions with MeeGo people - core Meego OS goes to meego.com and
> > Harmattan UI and UX are with maemo.org or something more strained than
> > that.  But the division is admittedly not good - we'll have to see.  I
> hope
> > we get some clarity at the conference.
>
> As said there is no "Core MeeGo OS" in Harmattan.
>
>
Thanks Ville.  As to MeeGo compliance, I guess I meant that in a larger
sense, not the certification program, but I didn't know the core OS wasn't
MeeGo.  The extent of shared lineage I hope some more knowledgeable than I
can address in due course.  I know QGil is still trying to get the device
"accepted" in MeeGo community and his session was not accepted at
Conference.  It seems poor Harmattan may be the poor child born after its
parents divorced.

Can 2) and 4) be answered sometime before device release?  Although I
understand if the Nokia UX/UI cannot be known until the big reveal.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.maemo.org/pipermail/maemo-community/attachments/20110506/a936bc66/attachment.htm>